2012 was a big year for youth justice advocates. IYC-Murphysboro closed (though it was later reopened by IDOC as a reentry facility in 2018). Also in 2012, multiple lawsuits were filed against IDJJ. The MacArthur Justice Center and the Uptown People’s Law Center filed a class action lawsuit (M.H. v. Findley - formerly M.H. v. Monreal) against IDJJ, in the wake of insufficient state response to the findings in the Youth Reentry Improvement Report from 2011.
The ACLU of Illinois also filed a class action lawsuit against IDJJ, R.J. v. Bishop (now R.J. v. Mueller), which alleged that deficiencies in the conditions, services, and treatment of youth throughout IDJJ amounted to a violation of Due Process Clause of the U.S. Constitution. Rather than litigating the case, IDJJ and the ACLU of Illinois entered into a consent decree in December 2012, and the court shortly afterwards approved a remedial plan that required IDJJ to improve its education and mental health services, decrease staff to youth ratios, and prohibited the use of solitary confinement as a disciplinary tool. This consent decree is still active and subject to ongoing supervision in federal district court.